.vbw-planning/milestones/generator-enhancements/phases/01-generator-steps/01-VERIFICATION.md
Verified by: QA agent (deep tier, 30 checks) Date: 2026-02-11
| # | Check | Result | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Generator tests pass | PASS | 20 runs, 109 assertions, 0 failures, 0 errors |
| 2 | Workflow tests pass | PASS | 8 runs, 22 assertions, 0 failures, 0 errors |
| 3 | Full test suite passes | PASS | 867 runs, 2898 assertions, 0 failures, 0 errors |
| 4 | RuboCop clean | PASS | 376 files inspected, no offenses detected |
| 5 | Brakeman clean | PASS | 0 warnings, 0 errors |
| # | Check | Result | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6 | Public method order correct | PASS | Order is: add_routes_mount (L17), create_initializer (L24), configure_recurring_jobs (L36), patch_procfile_dev (L52), configure_queue_dispatcher (L70), print_next_steps (L90) |
| 7 | patch_procfile_dev handles 3 cases | PASS | Create (L64-66), append (L62-63), skip (L57-60) |
| 8 | configure_queue_dispatcher handles 4 cases | PASS | Missing file (L73-76), already configured (L80-83), needs patching (L85-87), no dispatchers (L254-256 via add_recurring_schedule_to_dispatchers!) |
| 9 | Private methods/constants in private section | PASS | PROCFILE_JOBS_ENTRY (L104), RECURRING_SCHEDULE_VALUE (L201), DEFAULT_DISPATCHER (L203), queue_config_has_recurring_schedule? (L209), add_recurring_schedule_to_dispatchers! (L229) -- all after private on L102 |
| 10 | frozen_string_literal: true on all new files | PASS | procfile_patcher.rb (L1), queue_config_patcher.rb (L1) both have it |
| 11 | Idempotency: both steps safe to run multiple times | PASS | patch_procfile_dev: checks /^jobs:/ before acting; configure_queue_dispatcher: checks has_recurring_schedule? before acting. Test test_does_not_duplicate_jobs_entry_when_rerun explicitly verifies. |
| 12 | YAML.safe_load uses aliases: true | PASS | Generator L78: YAML.safe_load(File.read(queue_path), aliases: true). QueueConfigPatcher L24: YAML.safe_load(path.read, aliases: true) |
| 13 | ProcfilePatcher matches /^jobs:/ regex | PASS | Both generator (L57) and ProcfilePatcher (L17) use /^jobs:/ regex |
| 14 | QueueConfigPatcher recursive dispatcher search | PASS | has_recurring_schedule? (L36-53) recursively iterates parsed.each_value, checks nested hashes, and also checks top-level dispatchers key for flat configs |
| 15 | Workflow has both new kwargs with defaults | PASS | procfile_patcher: ProcfilePatcher.new (L40), queue_config_patcher: QueueConfigPatcher.new (L41) |
| 16 | Workflow calls patchers in correct position | PASS | Called at L73-74, after initializer_patcher.ensure_navigation_hint (L72) and before devise check (L76) |
| 17 | Autoload entries in lib/source_monitor.rb | PASS | ProcfilePatcher (L164), QueueConfigPatcher (L165) both present in Setup module autoloads |
| 18 | No hardcoded paths or env-specific assumptions | PASS | Paths are relative to destination_root (generator) or injected via constructor kwargs (patcher classes). No absolute paths. |
| 19 | Test isolation (no cross-test contamination) | PASS | Generator tests use prepare_destination in setup. Workflow tests use Spy/Mock objects for all collaborators. No shared state. WORKER_SUFFIX handles parallel workers. |
| 20 | say_status calls use correct symbols | PASS | :create (L66), :append (L63), :skip (L58, L74, L81), :info (L91-99) -- all correct |
| # | Check | Result | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 21 | Procfile.dev has jobs: with different content | PASS | Regex /^jobs:/ matches any line starting with jobs: regardless of the command after it. Correctly skips without overwriting. |
| 22 | queue.yml nested environments with different dispatchers | PASS | queue_config_has_recurring_schedule? recursively walks all hash values. add_recurring_schedule_to_dispatchers! processes all nested dispatcher arrays under any env key. Both handle flat and nested configs. |
| 23 | queue.yml empty/nil after parsing | PASS | L78: ` |
| 24 | Procfile.dev has trailing newlines | PASS | When appending (L62), uses puts("", PROCFILE_JOBS_ENTRY) which adds a blank line before the jobs entry. This handles trailing newlines gracefully -- the blank line acts as separator. |
| 25 | queue.yml dispatchers is empty array | PASS | If dispatchers: [], the any? check in has_recurring_schedule? returns false (no items to check). add_recurring_schedule_to_dispatchers! iterates the empty array (no-op) but sets found_dispatchers = true since the key exists. This means an empty dispatchers array stays empty with no recurring_schedule added. Minor note: This is a debatable edge case -- an empty dispatchers array means the user intentionally has no dispatchers, so not adding one is reasonable behavior. |
| # | Check | Result | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 26 | REQ-16: Generator patches Procfile.dev | PASS | patch_procfile_dev creates/appends/skips as needed. 4 tests cover all scenarios. |
| 27 | REQ-17: Generator patches queue.yml | PASS | configure_queue_dispatcher patches/skips/handles-missing as needed. 4 tests cover all scenarios. |
| 28 | REQ-18: Workflow integrates both | PASS | workflow.rb L73-74 calls both patchers. Workflow test L96-97 verifies both are called. |
| 29 | Test count increased | PASS | Was 841, now 867 (+26 tests: 8 new generator tests + 18 other additions from this phase) |
| 30 | No regressions in existing tests | PASS | Full suite: 867 runs, 2898 assertions, 0 failures, 0 errors |
Empty dispatchers array edge case (Check #25): If queue.yml has dispatchers: [], the code sees found_dispatchers = true (the key exists) but doesn't add any recurring_schedule since there are no dispatcher hashes to iterate. This means the empty array is left as-is. This is arguably correct behavior (respecting user intent), but worth documenting.
Generator test count: The plan expected "11 existing + 8 new = 19" but the actual count is 20 (12 existing + 8 new). The plan summary correctly notes 20. The 12th existing test was likely the test_outputs_next_steps_with_doc_links test that was already present. No issue -- just a plan estimate mismatch.
No blocking issues found.
Risk level: LOW