ContextQMD
Back to Reactive Resume

Independent review: plan 02 synthetic recovery

docs/execution/briefs/review-plan-02.md

5.3.02.1 KB
Original Source

Independent review: plan 02 synthetic recovery

Review only; do not edit, commit, push, open PR, mutate issues, or spawn subagents. Read current worktree AGENTS.md, RTK, issue/domain guidance, code-review/receiving-code-review/testing skills, implementation report .orchestration/plan-02-implementation.md, and approved plan 02. Trust local planning checkout only when HEAD equals a2557b2ad40e06e1e63eb655f286e6a78fe6bf0d; otherwise read git show a2557b2ad40e06e1e63eb655f286e6a78fe6bf0d:plans/02-hosted-v4-account-recovery.md.

Fetch current origin/main and GitHub issue/PR state. Confirm reviewed branch/commit and inspect complete origin/main...HEAD diff. Treat prior report as a claim to verify. Review standards and approved-plan fidelity, especially:

  • Comparator is pure, deterministic, non-networked, non-writing, current-schema-only, and never implies owner/source authenticity from hashes. Validate no import-time effects or accidental sensitive logging.
  • Manifest contracts and tests correctly cover identical, old-only, divergent, owner/mapping/source blocks, malformed input, determinism, immutability, and stable IDs/hashes. Seek false positives and weak self-fulfilling tests.
  • Docs distinguish hosted operator authority from self-hosted authority, require owner verification/mapping/private delivery, forbid overwrite/default public exposure, state no-source limits, and make no v4 conversion/recovery promise.
  • Scope contains exactly four approved files. No private data or destructive recovery steps.

Rerun focused tooling test/typecheck, relevant API/auth tests, affected typechecks, boundaries, narrow Biome/Markdown checks, and git diff --check; rerun broader tests only where a finding needs proof. Record skipped gates. Findings first, ordered by severity with exact file/line and concrete evidence. If none, state No findings and residual risks.

Write .orchestration/plan-02-review.md with reviewed SHA/base, findings, commands/results, skipped gates, risks, and verdict ready for publication or changes required. Final response at most ten lines.