Slate v2 Phase 9 Checkpoint

Supporting plan. For current queue and roadmap truth, see master-roadmap.md.

Goal

Use the current breadth of the compatibility matrix and the family ledger to decide whether the roadmap should keep defaulting to Phase 9 matrix widening or pivot to Phase 10 release-readiness.

Current Evidence

• the replacement matrix now covers:
  • core anchor lifecycle
  • inline family
  • placeholder family
  • decoration/highlight family
  • anchor/projection family
  • plaintext/read-only editorial family
  • browser-boundary family
  • several broad legacy-only structural/editorial families
• the family ledger now distinguishes:
  • preserved
  • redefined
  • comparison-only
  • intentionally later

Decision Question

Has Phase 9 reached the point where more default matrix farming is lower value than starting the Phase 10 release-readiness gate?

Decision

Yes.

Phase 9 is now broad enough that it should stop being the default queue.

Why:

• the matrix now covers the anchor, inline, placeholder, decoration, anchor, editorial, browser-boundary, and several structural/media comparison families
• the family ledger now distinguishes:
  • preserved
  • redefined
  • comparison-only
  • intentionally later
• remaining family rows are now lower-leverage unless they materially change the replacement decision

So the default queue should pivot to:

• Phase 10 release-readiness

while Phase 9 remains available only for selective follow-on work when a family row or benchmark would materially change the claim.