Back to Oh My Openagent

HEAVY self-review

.omo/evidence/20260727-senpi-task-always-steer/06-self-review.md

4.19.32.3 KB
Original Source

HEAVY self-review

Criterion review

  • Criterion 1: schema, runtime, and renderer RED→GREEN evidence is specific and behavior-sensitive.
  • Criterion 2: live running-child steer passed through the Senpi RPC harness; resident revival passed through a direct changed-library driver. The broader mock-provider E2E failure occurred before task_send and is disclosed.
  • Criterion 3: package tests, compatibility, typecheck, build, and diff checks passed. LSP was unavailable and is disclosed.
  • Criterion 4: pending PR/reviewer/merge.

Programming post-write review

  1. Single responsibility: PASS. send-schema.ts owns the public input schema; send.ts owns task_send routing; renderers.ts owns control-tool rendering; the new test owns the always-steer public contract.
  2. Boundary purity: PASS. TypeBox remains the boundary parser, and removing deliver_as makes invalid delivery modes unrepresentable in TaskSendInput.
  3. Variant discrimination: PASS. Structured messages and result variants remain exhaustively switched with assertNever.
  4. Escape hatches: PASS. No any, suppression, non-null assertion, or ignored diagnostic was added.
  5. Defensive layer: PASS. The patch removes obsolete delivery validation branches rather than adding redundant checks.
  6. One-off helpers: PASS. No new production helper was introduced.
  7. Tests: PASS. Reverting the schema/runtime/renderer change reproduces the three captured RED failures.
  8. Parameter bloat: PASS. No function gained parameters; validateParams was simplified from three parameters to one.
  9. Redundant verification: PASS. Runtime cleanup checks are QA receipts, not production setter/getter duplication.
  10. Negative naming: PASS. No new negative-form production name was added.
  11. Logging: PASS. No logging behavior changed.

Size check

Command:

bash
bun run packages/omo-senpi/plugin/skills/programming/scripts/typescript/check-no-excuse-rules.ts <14 changed TypeScript files>

Result: No violations in 14 file(s).

Review-driven cleanup

The self-review found that the control-layer SendManager, SendResultDetails, and renderer still carried unreachable interrupt/no-op variants after the public option was removed. Those dead public-control variants were removed while preserving the lower-level manager/steering interrupt API used by internal lifecycle and adversarial tests.