ContextQMD
Back to Oh My Openagent

Reviewer-fix report - independent review blockers

.omo/evidence/20260721-ulw-loop-gajae-adoption/reviewer-fix-report.md

4.19.12.2 KB
Original Source

Reviewer-fix report - independent review blockers

What changed

  • Batch rejection now appends exactly one steering_rejected ledger entry, with message listing each rejected item index and its reasons. Plan writes remain zero on rejection.
  • appendLedgerEntries(repoRoot, entries, scope) was added and accepted batch steering now writes all fresh accepted/criteria-revised entries plus any batch_updated entry in one filesystem append after one writePlan. Deduped items remain audit-free.
  • CLI steering rejects simultaneous --kind and --proposals-json before mutation with typed code ULW_LOOP_STEERING_BATCH_CONFLICT and exit 1.
  • Validation-batch schema failures now use the approved distinct codes: ULW_LOOP_VALIDATION_BATCH_MEMBER_UNKNOWN, ULW_LOOP_VALIDATION_BATCH_FINAL_NOT_MEMBER, and ULW_LOOP_VALIDATION_BATCH_OVERLAP; structural invalidity, duplicate members, and too-small batches retain ULW_LOOP_VALIDATION_BATCH_INVALID.

RED/GREEN evidence

  • RED commands and observed failures are preserved in reviewer-fix-transcript.txt.
  • GREEN gates: focused Vitest seam, npm run check, full component npm test, hands-on built-CLI QA, and root bun run test:codex all passed.

Supersession note

Prior task/F evidence remains historical for the original feature delivery. This report and reviewer-fix-transcript.txt supersede the earlier task-2/task-3/task-6/F1-F4 claims for the independent-review blocker details: rejection audit durability, plural accepted-batch append, CLI conflict typing, validation-batch branch codes, final component test count, and final scope state.

Cleanup and scope

  • The failed and passing reviewer-fix QA temp repos were removed; receipts are in reviewer-fix-transcript.txt.
  • Real ~/.codex/config.toml hash stayed 780c740e287bda48609b5c9d5ee3ee2fc20434ce1a58c36692ec07e279a161d5.
  • Root gate generated an out-of-scope CodeGraph dist comment rewrite; it was restored byte-for-byte from the clean main worktree before this evidence commit.
  • The final evidence commit intentionally includes deletion of the three previously accidental .omo runtime files: .omo/boulder.json, .omo/plans/ulw-loop-gajae-adoption.md, and .omo/start-work/ledger.jsonl.