Back to Oh My Openagent

F2 code quality review - APPROVE

.omo/evidence/20260721-ulw-loop-gajae-adoption/f2.md

4.19.12.6 KB
Original Source

F2 code quality review - APPROVE

What was tested

  • Historical npm run check && npm test in the ulw-loop component after original feature fixes.
  • Reviewer-fix npm run check and full npm test after independent-review blocker fixes.
  • Pure LOC audit on every changed TypeScript file using awk '!/^[[:space:]]*$/ && !/^[[:space:]]*\/\//' <file> | wc -l.
  • Forbidden construct audit over the diff for as any, as unknown, @ts-ignore, non-null assertions, default exports, and enums.
  • Given/when/then discipline audit in new/changed tests.

Gate output

  • npm run check: passed (tsc --noEmit, biome check ., tsc -p tsconfig.build.json).
  • Historical npm test: passed (40 files, 412 tests).
  • Reviewer-fix npm test: passed (40 files, 418 tests).

Pure LOC audit

All changed TypeScript files are <=250 pure LOC; steering.ts is 203, under its stricter 240 budget.

Pure LOCFile
76src/checkpoint-continuation.ts
249src/checkpoint.ts
79src/cli-arg-parser.ts
107src/cli-commands.ts
73src/cli-output.ts
140src/cli-steering.ts
217src/cli-subcommands.ts
134src/codex-goal-instruction.ts
58src/constants.ts
159src/domain-types.ts
90src/goal-status.ts
199src/plan-crud.ts
174src/plan-io.ts
20src/quality-gate-verdicts.ts
115src/steering-batch.ts
52src/steering-mutations.ts
203src/steering.ts
175src/stop-resume-hook.ts
105src/validation-batch.ts
63test/checkpoint-continuation.test.ts
99test/cli-checkpoint-continuation.test.ts
55test/cli-steering-batch.test.ts
49test/cli-validation-batch.test.ts
72test/paths.test.ts
127test/steering-batch.test.ts
130test/validation-batch-checkpoint.test.ts
61test/validation-batch.test.ts

Forbidden construct audit

No matches in the diff for as any, as unknown, @ts-ignore, non-null assertions, default exports, or enums.

Test style audit

New/changed tests contain given/when/then naming or comments. Counts after reviewer fixes include checkpoint-continuation 3, cli-checkpoint-continuation 2, cli-steering-batch 3, cli-validation-batch 2, steering-batch 5, validation-batch-checkpoint 6, validation-batch 6.

LSP diagnostics note

The LSP tool rejects paths outside the request cwd (/Users/yeongyu/local-workspaces/omo), and this task worktree is /Users/yeongyu/local-workspaces/omo-wt/ulw-loop-batch-efficiency-v2. I attempted diagnostics and received LSP file path must be inside request cwd. TypeScript diagnostics were covered by tsc --noEmit in npm run check and npm run typecheck during focused fixes.