Back to Oh My Openagent

F1 plan compliance audit - APPROVE

.omo/evidence/20260721-ulw-loop-gajae-adoption/f1.md

4.19.12.7 KB
Original Source

F1 plan compliance audit - APPROVE

What was tested

  • Re-read the approved plan in .omo/plans/ulw-loop-gajae-adoption.md.
  • Audited git diff --stat origin/dev...HEAD.
  • Re-ran focused acceptance suites historically: npm test -- checkpoint steering validation-batch create-goals (16 files, 131 tests passed).
  • Re-ran independent-review blocker suites: npm test -- steering-batch cli-steering-batch validation-batch cli-validation-batch (5 files, 22 tests passed), npm run check, full component npm test (40 files, 418 tests passed), and root bun run test:codex (510 tests passed).
  • Re-ran todo-5 help/doc checks: node dist/cli.js ulw-loop help | grep -E -- '--no-advance|--proposals-json|--validation-batch-json', rg -c "complete-goals" README.md skills/ulw-loop/references/full-workflow.md, rg "proposals-json" README.md.
  • Checked Must-NOT scope: git diff --stat origin/dev...HEAD -- packages/omo-opencode empty; no pipeline-overlap symbols; plan schema remains version 1; out-of-scope CodeGraph generated diff from root gate was restored to empty before evidence commit.

Compliance table

Plan itemResultEvidence
checkpoint complete auto-advances and --no-advance preserves old flowShippedtask-6-e2e-transcript.txt, F3 legacy probe
steer --proposals-json atomic batchShipped + blocker-fixedtask-6-e2e-transcript.txt, F3 dedup/fresh probe, reviewer-fix-transcript.txt
validation batches in create-goals and fail-closed enforcementShipped + blocker-fixedtask-6-e2e-transcript.txt, F3 mismatch probe, reviewer-fix-transcript.txt
docs/help syncShippedhelp/doc grep commands above
QA evidence under .omo/evidence/20260721-ulw-loop-gajae-adoption/Shipped + superseded where notedREADME + task/F artifacts + reviewer-fix report/transcript
no pipeline-overlap / @goal: / HUD portCleangrep audit found no new forbidden symbols; existing reconcileCodexGoalSnapshot references are pre-existing snapshot reconciliation, not the forbidden gajae reconcile/HUD surface
no root CLI / installer / hooks scope creepCleanpackages/omo-opencode diff empty; final intentional deliverables are ulw-loop component changes and .omo/evidence/**; accidental .omo runtime files are deleted in the evidence commit
schema version stays 1Cleandomain-types.ts and plan-crud.ts still use version: 1

What was observed

All must-have behavior is present, including the independent-review blocker fixes. Must-NOT items are absent, except the expected existing reconcileCodexGoalSnapshot symbol which predates this work and is not the prohibited gajae reconcile/HUD port.

What was omitted

No PR operation was performed.