ContextQMD
Back to Oh My Openagent

Review6 Context Gate - Todo 4 Category Repair6

.omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/review6/context.md

4.16.010.0 KB
Original Source

Review6 Context Gate - Todo 4 Category Repair6

recommendation: PASS verdict: PASS confidence: HIGH

Worktree: /Users/yeongyu/local-workspaces/omo-wt/senpi-task-w0-category Branch: code-yeongyu/senpi-task-w0-category Base: 27fc9ca95abfa266e0b2e0e3efa44b56ec8b9ab4 HEAD reviewed: 70c148a2fa84d1a531903a34904f9a60a4d23f0f Report path: /Users/yeongyu/local-workspaces/omo-wt/senpi-task-w0-category/.omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/review6/context.md

originalIntent

Todo 4 requires packages/senpi-task/src/category to port the eight OpenCode delegate-task builtin category defaults, overlay omoConfig.categories, delegate the seven-step model selection order to @oh-my-opencode/delegate-core, map the selected provider/model through Senpi ModelRegistry.find(provider, id), and return a typed unavailable result when the chosen model cannot safely resolve. The Todo explicitly blocks future Todo 9 TaskManager and Todo 14 task-tool category routing.

desiredOutcome

resolveCategory() should only return kind: "resolved" when the ResolvedChildSpec identity matches the exact selected lookup identity. Empty or mismatched registry find() identities must return sanitized model_unavailable, preserving the attempted selected model without leaking malformed registry data. Future Todos 9 and 14 can then trust a resolved category spec to identify the model that delegate-core selected.

userOutcomeReview

PASS. Repair6 closes the Review5 context blocker. parseRegistryModel() now rejects empty own string identities and, when used for ModelRegistry.find(), requires exact equality with the requested { provider, modelId } before a ResolvedChildSpec can be constructed. The selected lookup identity is passed into parseRegistryModel() at the find() boundary, so future Todo 9 and Todo 14 consumers can trust that a resolved category spec matches modelSelection.selectedModel.

No new blocking plan/context miss was found. Repair6 did not add category XOR agent logic, did not add runtime omo-opencode imports, did not locally implement the seven-step model order, and did not omit a future dependency that blocks Todo 4.

blockers

None.

priorFailureClosure

  • Review5 blocker: ModelRegistry.find(provider, id) results with { provider: "", id: "" }, { provider: "evil", id: "other" }, or { provider: "openai", id: "" } could produce resolved.
  • Production repair checked: packages/senpi-task/src/category/resolver.ts:81-93 rejects empty identities and exact mismatches; packages/senpi-task/src/category/resolver.ts:236-238 calls parseRegistryModel(..., parsedModel) for find().
  • Unit coverage checked: packages/senpi-task/src/category/resolve-category-boundary.test.ts:154-184 covers empty identity, mismatched identity, and empty model id.
  • Manual QA checked: packages/senpi-task/scripts/manual-category-qa.ts:158-178 covers the same malformed identity cases.
  • Red/green evidence checked: repair6-registry-identity/red-focused-boundary.log failed on the new identity test before the fix; green-focused-boundary.log passed after the fix.

futureDependencyReview

  • Todo 9 depends on category(4) through TaskManager composition and uses category output to choose concurrency key {provider}/{model} and runner specs. Since resolved.spec.provider/modelId must now match the selected lookup identity, the manager is not handed a category spec for a different or empty registry model.
  • Todo 14 depends on category(4) when spawning via task(category: ...). The repair means the tool layer can treat resolved as a trustworthy child-spec identity and can route model_unavailable for malformed registry results instead of adding duplicate identity checks there.

noScopeDrift

  • Category XOR agent logic: searched scoped category/source files for subagent_type, XOR, and category/agent routing terms. No matches in Todo 4 scope.
  • Runtime omo-opencode import: precise import/export/require guard over packages/senpi-task/src and packages/senpi-task/scripts returned no executable imports. Broad matches are source comments only.
  • Local seven-step order: scoped search found the single resolveModelForDelegateTask call and fallback-chain data, plus incidental .sort() for category/model display ordering. No local model-order algorithm was added.
  • Docs/future dependency omission: Todo 4, Todo 9, and Todo 14 plan lines still describe category as the dependency, and repair6 does not require a new future-todo plan change to unblock this PR.

directVerification

Commands I ran directly in the worktree:

  • bun test packages/senpi-task/src/category/resolve-category-boundary.test.ts -> 9 pass, 0 fail.
  • bun test packages/senpi-task/src/category -> 19 pass, 0 fail, 1 snapshot.
  • bun run typecheck -> exit 0.
  • bun run packages/senpi-task/scripts/manual-category-qa.ts -> exit 0; identityFind returned model_unavailable for all three malformed identity cases.
  • bun run packages/shared-skills/skills/programming/scripts/typescript/check-no-excuse-rules.ts packages/senpi-task/src/category packages/senpi-task/scripts/manual-category-qa.ts packages/senpi-task/src/index.ts -> No violations in 13 file(s).
  • Pure LOC check over category files -> all <=250 pure LOC; largest is resolver.ts at 248.
  • git status --short --untracked-files=all before report write -> clean.

slopAndProgrammingReview

Loaded and applied programming, TypeScript programming references, and remove-ai-slops directly. The repair is not unnecessary extraction, not deletion-only, not a tautological test-only change, and not implementation-mirroring in a way that creates false confidence. The new test asserts observable result kind, attempted selected identity, available model list, and absence of mismatched identity leakage. Production logic is a scoped boundary parser hardening at the registry trust boundary, which matches parse-don't-validate and typed-result expectations.

Existing report coverage checked: review5/code-quality.md and review5/security.md explicitly include programming/remove-ai-slops perspective checks. Repair6's own report.md does not have a separate skill-heading, so I did not rely on that claim; this report extends the skill/slop pass over the repair6 delta directly.

artifactReview

Checked artifact paths:

  • .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/review5/context.md
  • .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/review5/security.md
  • .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/review5/code-quality.md
  • .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/review6/qa.md
  • .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/repair6-registry-identity/report.md
  • .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/repair6-registry-identity/CLEANUP-RECEIPT.md
  • .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/repair6-registry-identity/red-focused-boundary.log
  • .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/repair6-registry-identity/green-focused-boundary.log
  • .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/repair6-registry-identity/green-category-dir.log
  • .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/repair6-registry-identity/typecheck.log
  • .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/repair6-registry-identity/no-excuse.log
  • .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/repair6-registry-identity/static-no-omo-opencode-import.log
  • .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/repair6-registry-identity/static-no-local-seven-step-order.log
  • .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/repair6-registry-identity/manual-category-qa.log
  • .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/repair6-registry-identity/postclaim-stop-hook-1/POSTCLAIM-VERIFICATION.md
  • .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/repair6-registry-identity/postclaim-stop-hook-2/POSTCLAIM-VERIFICATION.md
  • .omo/plans/senpi-task.md
  • packages/senpi-task/src/category/resolver.ts
  • packages/senpi-task/src/category/resolve-category-boundary.test.ts
  • packages/senpi-task/src/category/resolve-category.test.ts
  • packages/senpi-task/src/category/types.ts
  • packages/senpi-task/src/index.ts
  • packages/senpi-task/scripts/manual-category-qa.ts

Artifact caveat: review6/qa.md reports FAIL from a raw wc -l LOC gate. The applicable repo/programming rule is pure LOC, and my pure-LOC check shows all scoped files are within the <=250 ceiling. I treat that QA report's raw-line conclusion as a false-positive artifact issue, not a context blocker.

sourcesSearched

  • Local git: branch, HEAD, HEAD^..HEAD repair6 diff, base-to-HEAD changed-file list.
  • Local plan: .omo/plans/senpi-task.md Todo 4, Todo 9, Todo 14 dependency text.
  • Local code refs: resolveCategory, CategoryModelUnavailable/model_unavailable, mismatched, empty identity/provider, prompt_append, reasoningEffort, ModelRegistry, ResolvedChildSpec, subagent_type, category/agent routing, runtime imports, and model-order terms.
  • Evidence reports/logs under .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/ for review5, repair6, review6 QA, and postclaim verification.
  • GitHub via gh: repo metadata, PR search for senpi-task category, exact branch code-yeongyu/senpi-task-w0-category, commit/title search for 70c148a2f / validate category registry identity, and issue search for senpi-task category / category registry identity.

sourcesSkipped

  • Slack: skipped, no Slack connector/tool available in this session.
  • Notion: skipped, no Notion connector/tool available in this session.
  • Codegraph: skipped after the codegraph tool reported the target worktree was not indexed, despite a local .codegraph directory being visible to shell search.

exactEvidenceGaps

No blocking evidence gaps remain for the Review5 context blocker or repair6 context scope.

Nonblocking artifact gap: review6/qa.md uses raw line count instead of pure LOC and therefore conflicts with the repo rule. This does not change the context verdict because the direct pure-LOC check passed.

missedRequirements

None found.

finalVerdict

PASS. The prior ModelRegistry.find identity validation gap is satisfied, future Todo 9/14 can trust resolved category identity, and no new blocking context or scope-drift requirement remains.