.omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/review5/qa.md
Verdict: FAIL Confidence: high
Reason: the category behavior, package tests, typecheck, manual QA script, static runtime-import guard, static order-delegation guard, corrected no-excuse checker path, adversarial boundary coverage, cleanup receipt, and zero-byte audit passed. The required fresh QA command using scripts/typescript/check-no-excuse-rules.ts failed because that path does not exist in this worktree. A corrected equivalent at packages/shared-skills/skills/programming/scripts/typescript/check-no-excuse-rules.ts passed, but the required command itself did not.
| Command | Exit | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
git status --short --untracked-files=all before | 0 | qa/01-git-status-before.* |
bun test packages/senpi-task/src/category | 0 | qa/02-bun-test-category.* |
bun test packages/senpi-task --bail | 0 | qa/03-bun-test-senpi-task-bail.* |
bun run typecheck | 0 | qa/04-bun-run-typecheck.* |
bun run packages/senpi-task/scripts/manual-category-qa.ts | 0 | qa/05-manual-category-qa.* |
bun run scripts/typescript/check-no-excuse-rules.ts ... | 1 | qa/06-check-no-excuse-rules.* |
rg -n "omo-opencode|@oh-my-opencode/omo-opencode" ... broad reference guard | 1 | qa/07-static-no-omo-opencode-import.* |
rg -n "delegate-core|fallback|..." ... audit | 0 | qa/08-static-model-order-audit.* |
rg -n "malformed|truthy|find|..." ... adversarial test map | 0 | qa/09-adversarial-test-source-map.* |
rg --files | rg '(^|/)check-no-excuse-rules\.ts$...' | 0 | qa/10-no-excuse-script-path-discovery.* |
bun run packages/shared-skills/skills/programming/scripts/typescript/check-no-excuse-rules.ts ... | 0 | qa/11-check-no-excuse-rules-corrected-path.* |
rg -n "^(import|export).*omo-opencode" ... import-only guard | 0 | qa/12-static-no-runtime-omo-opencode-import.* |
bash qa/static-order-delegation-guard.sh | 0 | qa/13-static-order-delegation-guard.*, qa/static-order-delegation-guard.sh |
final git status --short --untracked-files=all after report write | 0 | qa/34-git-status-final-clean.* |
| final zero-byte check after report write | 0 | qa/36-zero-byte-check-final-clean.* |
| cleanup receipt | 0 | qa/16-cleanup-receipt.* |
| Scenario | Criterion | Surface | Exact invocation | Verdict | artifactRefs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S1 | Category unit/boundary suite passes | CLI test runner | bun test packages/senpi-task/src/category | PASS | A02 |
| S2 | Full senpi-task package suite passes | CLI test runner | bun test packages/senpi-task --bail | PASS | A03 |
| S3 | Workspace typecheck passes including senpi-task | CLI typecheck | bun run typecheck | PASS | A04 |
| S4 | Manual category QA proves happy, disabled, unavailable, hardcoded fallback, system default, and boundary-shaped data scenarios | CLI/data script | bun run packages/senpi-task/scripts/manual-category-qa.ts | PASS | A05 |
| S5 | Required no-excuse command path passes | CLI checker | bun run scripts/typescript/check-no-excuse-rules.ts ... | FAIL | A06 |
| S6 | Corrected no-excuse checker path passes | CLI checker | bun run packages/shared-skills/skills/programming/scripts/typescript/check-no-excuse-rules.ts ... | PASS | A10, A11 |
| S7 | No runtime omo-opencode import from senpi-task category/source files | Static source guard | rg -n "^(import|export).*omo-opencode" packages/senpi-task/scripts/manual-category-qa.ts packages/senpi-task/src/category packages/senpi-task/src/index.ts | PASS | A12 |
| S8 | No local implementation of the 7-step model order beyond delegate-core and fallback chain data | Static source guard | bash .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/review5/qa/static-order-delegation-guard.sh | PASS | A13 |
| S9 | Worktree starts and ends clean outside ignored evidence | Git data surface | git status --short --untracked-files=all | PASS | A01, A34 |
| S10 | Todo 4 evidence and review5 artifacts are non-empty | Filesystem data surface | find .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category -type f -size 0 -print | PASS | A36 |
| S11 | Cleanup receipt: no servers, tmux sessions, temp dirs, or background processes intentionally left | Terminal/OS data surface | cleanup receipt command in qa/16-cleanup-receipt.stdout | PASS | A16 |
| Scenario | Criterion | Adversarial class | Expected behavior | Verdict | artifactRefs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A1 | Boundary suite covers malformed truthy find() | Malformed truthy model objects and secret-like own fields | model_unavailable, no throw, no hidden leak | PASS | A02, A03, A05, A09 |
| A2 | Boundary suite covers non-array getAvailable | null, array-like object, and string availability containers | model_unavailable, empty available models, no throw | PASS | A02, A03, A05, A09 |
| A3 | Boundary suite covers legal headers metadata | Own provider/id model with legal headers object | Accepted and resolved | PASS | A02, A03, A05, A09 |
| A4 | Boundary suite covers own secret-like fields | Own password, accessToken, privateToken fields | Rejected as unavailable and sanitized | PASS | A02, A03, A05, A09 |
| A5 | Boundary suite covers inherited provider/id | Prototype provider/id/privateToken fields | Rejected as unavailable and sanitized | PASS | A02, A03, A05, A09 |
| A6 | Boundary suite covers throwing own accessor provider/id | Throwing accessor model from getAvailable and find | Does not throw; returns sanitized unavailable result | PASS | A02, A03, A05, A09 |
| id | kind | description | path |
|---|---|---|---|
| A01 | command capture | Initial git status stdout/stderr/exit | /Users/yeongyu/local-workspaces/omo-wt/senpi-task-w0-category/.omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/review5/qa/01-git-status-before.* |
| A02 | command capture | Category test suite, 18 pass / 0 fail | /Users/yeongyu/local-workspaces/omo-wt/senpi-task-w0-category/.omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/review5/qa/02-bun-test-category.* |
| A03 | command capture | Full senpi-task suite, 47 pass / 0 fail | /Users/yeongyu/local-workspaces/omo-wt/senpi-task-w0-category/.omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/review5/qa/03-bun-test-senpi-task-bail.* |
| A04 | command capture | Workspace typecheck | /Users/yeongyu/local-workspaces/omo-wt/senpi-task-w0-category/.omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/review5/qa/04-bun-run-typecheck.* |
| A05 | command capture | Manual category QA JSON output | /Users/yeongyu/local-workspaces/omo-wt/senpi-task-w0-category/.omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/review5/qa/05-manual-category-qa.* |
| A06 | command capture | Required no-excuse command failure: module path missing | /Users/yeongyu/local-workspaces/omo-wt/senpi-task-w0-category/.omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/review5/qa/06-check-no-excuse-rules.* |
| A09 | source map | Grep map from adversarial criteria to exact boundary tests/lines | /Users/yeongyu/local-workspaces/omo-wt/senpi-task-w0-category/.omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/review5/qa/09-adversarial-test-source-map.* |
| A10 | path discovery | Located corrected no-excuse checker under shared skills | /Users/yeongyu/local-workspaces/omo-wt/senpi-task-w0-category/.omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/review5/qa/10-no-excuse-script-path-discovery.* |
| A11 | command capture | Corrected no-excuse checker path, no violations in 13 files | /Users/yeongyu/local-workspaces/omo-wt/senpi-task-w0-category/.omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/review5/qa/11-check-no-excuse-rules-corrected-path.* |
| A12 | static guard | Import-only no runtime omo-opencode import guard | /Users/yeongyu/local-workspaces/omo-wt/senpi-task-w0-category/.omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/review5/qa/12-static-no-runtime-omo-opencode-import.* |
| A13 | static guard | Delegate-core/order-delegation guard and helper script | /Users/yeongyu/local-workspaces/omo-wt/senpi-task-w0-category/.omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/review5/qa/13-static-order-delegation-guard.* |
| A16 | cleanup | Cleanup receipt | /Users/yeongyu/local-workspaces/omo-wt/senpi-task-w0-category/.omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/review5/qa/16-cleanup-receipt.* |
| A34 | command capture | Final git status after report write | /Users/yeongyu/local-workspaces/omo-wt/senpi-task-w0-category/.omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/review5/qa/34-git-status-final-clean.* |
| A36 | filesystem audit | Final zero-byte artifact check after report write | /Users/yeongyu/local-workspaces/omo-wt/senpi-task-w0-category/.omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-4-category/review5/qa/36-zero-byte-check-final-clean.* |
No product code was edited. The only intentional helper created is qa/static-order-delegation-guard.sh inside the review5 evidence directory. No servers, tmux sessions, temp dirs, or background processes were intentionally created. The final git status capture is empty, which indicates the worktree is clean from Git's perspective; the evidence directory is ignored.