Back to Oh My Openagent

Review Fix - PR #5906 Todo 2 Gate Failures

.omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-2-config-loader-writer/REVIEW-FIX.md

4.16.03.4 KB
Original Source

Review Fix - PR #5906 Todo 2 Gate Failures

What Was Tested

  • RED regression capture before production edits:
    • bun test packages/omo-config-core/src/writer/writer.test.ts packages/omo-config-core/src/loader/loader.test.ts packages/omo-config-core/src/loader/merge.test.ts
      • Artifact: .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-2-config-loader-writer/red-review-fix-all-20260706.txt
  • GREEN focused regression rerun:
    • bun test packages/omo-config-core/src/writer/writer.test.ts packages/omo-config-core/src/loader/loader.test.ts packages/omo-config-core/src/loader/merge.test.ts
      • Artifact: .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-2-config-loader-writer/green-focused-review-fix-20260706.txt
  • Required automated gates:
    • bun test packages/omo-config-core --bail
      • Artifact: .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-2-config-loader-writer/green-omo-config-core-review-fix-20260706.txt
    • bun test tests/omo-config-category-drift.test.ts --bail
      • Artifact: .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-2-config-loader-writer/green-category-drift-review-fix-20260706.txt
    • bun run typecheck
      • Artifact: .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-2-config-loader-writer/typecheck-review-fix-20260706.txt
    • git diff --check code-yeongyu/senpi-task-w0-config-schema...HEAD
      • Artifact: .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-2-config-loader-writer/diff-check-review-fix-20260706.txt
  • Manual QA through the real package API:
    • bun --eval "$(cat .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-2-config-loader-writer/manual-qa-eval-script.mjs)"
      • Artifact: .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-2-config-loader-writer/manual-qa-review-fix-20260706.txt
    • Cleanup receipt:
      • Artifact: .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-2-config-loader-writer/cleanup-receipt-review-fix-20260706.txt

What Was Observed

  • RED evidence reproduced all three review blockers:
    • malformed existing .omo/omo.jsonc did not throw before the fix;
    • nested unsafe keys survived under a newly assigned merged object;
    • user $XDG_CONFIG_HOME/omo/omo.json was ignored.
  • GREEN package test evidence passed with 11 pass, 0 fail.
  • Category drift guard passed with 1 pass, 0 fail.
  • Typecheck exited 0.
  • Diff whitespace check exited 0.
  • Manual QA observed:
    • user omo.json loaded from the XDG user config path with default_concurrency: 11;
    • malformed writer threw OmoConfigWriteError with operation parse, left original bytes unchanged, and left no temp file;
    • nested unsafe own keys were stripped and Object.prototype was not polluted.
  • Cleanup receipt showed no remaining manual fixture run directories.

Why It Is Enough

  • The unit regressions lock the exact broken seams named by the reviewer: user path detection, recursive merge sanitization, and malformed writer preflight.
  • The required package, drift, typecheck, and diff-check gates cover the affected package and the category parity boundary.
  • The manual bun --eval run imports the real public package API from the worktree and drives the three repaired behaviors against fresh evidence-local fixture directories.

What Was Omitted

  • No OpenCode or Codex harness QA was run because this repair stayed inside packages/omo-config-core/** and does not touch adapter config pipelines.
  • No real home or user config paths were written; all manual fixtures were created under .omo/evidence/senpi-task/task-2-config-loader-writer/manual-fixtures/ and removed during the run.
  • No secret-bearing logs, environment dumps, tokens, or auth headers were captured.