manualQa Matrix: fix-4163 Evidence Re-Audit

Verdict: PASS

surfaceEvidence

scenario id	criterion reference	surface	exact invocation	verdict	artifactRefs
S1	green-parent-wake-race-final.log: 3 pass, 4 expect calls	Bun unit test log artifact plus current Bun rerun	`rg -n '3 pass	4 expect\(\) calls' .omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/green-parent-wake-race-final.log; /Users/yeongyu/.bun/bin/bun test packages/omo-opencode/src/hooks/todo-continuation-enforcer/parent-wake-race.test.ts`	PASS
S2	red-parent-wake-race.log: original two-case RED	Bun failing-first log artifact	sed -n '1,220p' .omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/red-parent-wake-race.log	PASS	A2
S3	pre-dispatch RED -> GREEN final guard	Bun failing-first and passing log artifacts	sed -n '1,220p' .omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/red-pre-dispatch-parent-wake-race.log; sed -n '1,220p' .omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/green-pre-dispatch-parent-wake-race.log	PASS	A3, A4
S4	todo-continuation-suite-final.log: 124 pass	Bun suite log artifact plus current Bun rerun	`rg -n '124 pass	0 fail	212 expect' .omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/todo-continuation-suite-final.log; /Users/yeongyu/.bun/bin/bun test packages/omo-opencode/src/hooks/todo-continuation-enforcer`
S5	prompt-async-route-audit-final.log: 10 pass	Bun prompt-route audit log artifact plus current Bun rerun	`rg -n '10 pass	0 fail	10 expect' .omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/prompt-async-route-audit-final.log; /Users/yeongyu/.bun/bin/bun test packages/omo-opencode/src/shared/prompt-async-route-audit.test.ts`
S6	typecheck-final.log exits 0	Repository typecheck artifact plus current typecheck rerun	sed -n '1,180p' .omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/typecheck-final.log; PATH=/Users/yeongyu/.bun/bin:$PATH /Users/yeongyu/.bun/bin/bun run typecheck	PASS	A7, A15
S7	no-excuse-final.log says no violations	No-excuse log artifact	sed -n '1,180p' .omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/no-excuse-final.log	PASS	A8
S8	OpenCode QA common self-check proves isolated harness	OpenCode QA common harness log artifact	sed -n '1,220p' .omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/opencode-qa-common-self-check-rerun.log	PASS	A9
S9	OpenCode QA SSE self-test proves SSE surface	OpenCode QA SSE log artifact	sed -n '1,220p' .omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/opencode-qa-sse-self-test.log	PASS	A10
S10	OpenCode QA server smoke proves API surface	OpenCode QA server smoke log artifact	sed -n '1,260p' .omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/opencode-qa-server-smoke.log	PASS	A11
S11	qa-summary.md references final logs and justifies deterministic race test as faithful channel	QA summary markdown artifact	`rg -n 'green-parent-wake-race-final	red-parent-wake-race	red-pre-dispatch-parent-wake-race

adversarialCases

scenario id	criterion reference	adversarial class	expected behavior	verdict	artifactRefs
AC1	Current artifacts match current implementation	Stale green artifact	Current-tree reruns reproduce parent race, suite, prompt audit, and typecheck success rather than only relying on saved final logs	PASS	A12, A13, A14, A15
AC2	Failing-first evidence	False RED artifact or post-fix failure log mislabeled as RED	RED logs contain actual expectation failures with Expected: 0 and Received: 1 for the parent wake race windows	PASS	A2, A3
AC3	Final pre-dispatch guard	Partial fix that covers idle/post-countdown but misses dispatch-time race	Pre-dispatch RED shows third case failing; GREEN/final current rerun shows all three cases passing	PASS	A3, A4, A12
AC4	OpenCode faithful surfaces	Harness-only claims without isolation/API/SSE proof	Common self-check proves isolated XDG cleanup; SSE observes server.connected; server smoke proves /global/health, /doc, and HTTP 401 auth behavior	PASS	A9, A10, A11
AC5	Replay environment drift	Missing bun on shell PATH makes current rerun look like product failure	Failed PATH-only rerun is recorded, then absolute Bun/PATH-corrected reruns exit 0	PASS	A17, A12, A15
AC6	Summary drift	Summary points at stale/non-final files or omits live repro rationale	Summary names the final artifacts and states the deterministic test is the faithful channel because it controls the race predicates without model nondeterminism	PASS	A16

artifactRefs

id	kind	description	path
A1	log	Final green parent wake race artifact: 3 pass, 0 fail, 4 expect calls	.omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/green-parent-wake-race-final.log
A2	log	Original two-case RED artifact with two expectation failures	.omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/red-parent-wake-race.log
A3	log	Pre-dispatch RED artifact with third race case failing	.omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/red-pre-dispatch-parent-wake-race.log
A4	log	Pre-dispatch GREEN artifact with all three race cases passing	.omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/green-pre-dispatch-parent-wake-race.log
A5	log	Final full todo-continuation suite: 124 pass	.omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/todo-continuation-suite-final.log
A6	log	Final prompt async route audit: 10 pass	.omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/prompt-async-route-audit-final.log
A7	log	Final typecheck artifact with successful command transcript	.omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/typecheck-final.log
A8	log	Final no-excuse artifact: no violations in 3 files	.omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/no-excuse-final.log
A9	log	OpenCode QA common self-check rerun, including isolated XDG cleanup proof	.omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/opencode-qa-common-self-check-rerun.log
A10	log	OpenCode QA SSE self-test observing server.connected	.omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/opencode-qa-sse-self-test.log
A11	log	OpenCode QA server smoke proving health/doc/auth surfaces	.omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/opencode-qa-server-smoke.log
A12	log	Current-tree parent wake race rerun with absolute Bun path: 3 pass, 4 expect, exit 0	.omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/re-audit-current/parent-wake-race-current-absolute-bun.log
A13	log	Current-tree todo-continuation suite rerun: 124 pass, exit 0	.omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/re-audit-current/todo-continuation-suite-current.log
A14	log	Current-tree prompt async route audit rerun: 10 pass, exit 0	.omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/re-audit-current/prompt-async-route-audit-current.log
A15	log	Current-tree typecheck rerun with Bun on PATH: exit 0	.omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/re-audit-current/typecheck-current-with-path.log
A16	markdown	QA summary referencing final logs and explaining deterministic faithful channel	.omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/qa-summary.md
A17	log	Audit-only failed replay showing PATH-only bun was unavailable; not used as PASS evidence for product behavior	.omo/evidence/20260705-fix-4163/re-audit-current/parent-wake-race-current.log