Review Work Final Report

Overall Verdict

PASSED after review-evidence supplementation.

Lanes

#	Review area	Verdict	Confidence
1	Goal and constraint verification	PASS after gap resolution	HIGH
2	Manual QA execution	PASS	HIGH
3	Code quality	PASS	HIGH
4	Security	PASS	NONE severity
5	Context mining	PASS	HIGH

Initial Gate Gap

The first gate-review pass rejected the PR for process-evidence gaps, not for functional/code issues. It found selector runtime removal, adjacent hook preservation, QA evidence, and CI status were correct, but requested explicit current-task artifacts for:

• code-review report with remove-ai-slops coverage
• programming-skill perspective report
• manual QA matrix
• notepad path/artifact
• Cubic status recording

The requested artifacts are now present in this evidence directory.

Blocking Issues

None remaining.

Key Evidence

• Manual QA matrix: review-work-manual-qa.md
• Code-quality report with omo:remove-ai-slops, omo:programming, and code-review perspective checks: review-work-code-quality.md
• Security report with omo:remove-ai-slops, omo:programming, and security-diff perspective checks: review-work-security.md
• Context-mining report: review-work-context-mining.md
• Notepad artifact: notepad.md
• Cubic status: GitHub check cubic · AI code reviewer completed NEUTRAL / skipping and no Cubic review or issue comment was available. This is recorded as Gate C skipped.

CI

PR #5745 passed:

• build
• typecheck on macOS, Ubuntu, and Windows
• test on macOS, Ubuntu, and Windows
• codex-compatibility on macOS, Ubuntu, and Windows
• lazycodex-published-smoke
• CLA, labels, and GitGuardian

Conclusion

The runtime removal remains surgical: workflow selector component, hook manifest, package/workspace/lockfile entries, and aggregate plugin manifest wiring are gone. Existing Codex UserPromptSubmit hooks remain rules, ultrawork, and ulw-loop. No stale runtime references remain.