PR 5725 Final-Gate Code Review Artifact

Scope: evidence/process-only repair for PR code-yeongyu/add-workflow-selector-evidence against origin/dev.

Sources used:

• PR blocker comment: https://github.com/code-yeongyu/oh-my-openagent/pull/5725#issuecomment-4828691250
• Existing PR evidence under .omo/evidence/20260627-workflow-selector-esm-spy/
• PR body for https://github.com/code-yeongyu/oh-my-openagent/pull/5725

Review-Work Gate Summary

Status: satisfied by this final-gate report artifact.

The release gate blocker was process-only: the eight workflow-selector evidence files were already present, the PR diff was evidence-only, and Cubic was neutral so it could not stand in for the review-work/process review lane. This artifact adds the missing reviewer-readable final-gate summary without changing runtime code, source files, tests, package metadata, or generated dist files.

Binary observable:

• Invocation: git diff --name-only origin/dev..HEAD
• Observed before this repair: only files under .omo/evidence/20260627-workflow-selector-esm-spy/
• Artifact source: PR #5725 body and local diff readback

omo:remove-ai-slops

Coverage status: pass for evidence-only scope.

The overfit/slop risk in this PR is not a code cleanup risk because this branch does not modify source, tests, package metadata, or dist output. The slop review therefore checks the evidence itself for over-claiming, missing limitations, and unverifiable assertions.

Observed coverage:

• RED reproduction is captured at .omo/evidence/20260627-workflow-selector-esm-spy/red-npm-test-workflow-selector-esm-spy.txt. It records the ESM namespace spy failure: Cannot spy on export "readFileSync".
• GREEN focused package behavior is captured at .omo/evidence/20260627-workflow-selector-esm-spy/green-npm-test-workflow-selector-rebased.txt. It records 2 test files and 14 tests passing.
• The check/build lane is captured at .omo/evidence/20260627-workflow-selector-esm-spy/green-npm-check-workflow-selector-rebased.txt. It exits 0 and explicitly preserves the Biome informational suggestions as non-blocking output rather than hiding them.
• The app-server limitation is not overfit into a pass. It is captured as a failure before Codex launch in .omo/evidence/20260627-workflow-selector-esm-spy/codex-qa-app-server-drive-plugin.txt and summarized in .omo/evidence/20260627-workflow-selector-esm-spy/qa-limitation-codex-app-server.md.

Conclusion: no slop cleanup was applied, and none is appropriate for this evidence-only commit. The existing evidence includes the failed lane and its limitation instead of overstating coverage.

omo:programming

Coverage status: pass for maintenance/process scope.

The programming-maintenance review checks that the PR remains maintainable as a release evidence artifact:

• No implementation files are edited in PR #5725.
• No new test assertions, runtime hooks, CLI behavior, package metadata, or dist bundles are changed.
• The QA files are grouped in the existing workflow-selector evidence directory and named by scenario: RED reproduction, focused GREEN tests/checks, component build, bundled CLI contract, direct component CLI proof, app-server blocker, and limitation summary.
• The report preserves the exact artifact paths a reviewer can inspect without requiring local reconstruction of the earlier merged PR.

Conclusion: the branch is maintainable as a process/evidence-only follow-up. The appropriate programming gate here is scope control and traceability, not new code changes.

QA Evidence Lane

Status: partially complete with an explicit app-server limitation.

Captured QA artifacts:

• npm test --workspace components/workflow-selector
  • RED: .omo/evidence/20260627-workflow-selector-esm-spy/red-npm-test-workflow-selector-esm-spy.txt
  • GREEN: .omo/evidence/20260627-workflow-selector-esm-spy/green-npm-test-workflow-selector-rebased.txt
• npm run check --workspace components/workflow-selector
  • GREEN with informational Biome diagnostics and successful build: .omo/evidence/20260627-workflow-selector-esm-spy/green-npm-check-workflow-selector-rebased.txt
• node packages/omo-codex/plugin/scripts/build-components.mjs
  • GREEN: .omo/evidence/20260627-workflow-selector-esm-spy/codex-plugin-build-components-rebased.txt
• node --test packages/omo-codex/plugin/test/component-bundled-cli.test.mjs
  • GREEN, 7 tests passed: .omo/evidence/20260627-workflow-selector-esm-spy/codex-plugin-component-bundled-cli-test-rebased.txt
• Direct workflow-selector CLI proof:
  • Invocation: OMO_CODEX_AUTO_WORKFLOW=1 node packages/omo-codex/plugin/components/workflow-selector/dist/cli.js hook user-prompt-submit
  • GREEN: .omo/evidence/20260627-workflow-selector-esm-spy/codex-component-cli-workflow-selector-rebased.txt
  • Binary observable: exit 0, output contains <lazycodex-auto-workflow>, $ulw-loop, and manual QA evidence.
• First-party app-server QA attempt:
  • Invocation: OMO_CODEX_AUTO_WORKFLOW=1 bash .agents/skills/codex-qa/scripts/app-server-drive.sh --plugin --prompt <debug prompt> --expect sessionStart,userPromptSubmit
  • Blocked before Codex launch: .omo/evidence/20260627-workflow-selector-esm-spy/codex-qa-app-server-drive-plugin.txt
  • Reviewer summary: .omo/evidence/20260627-workflow-selector-esm-spy/qa-limitation-codex-app-server.md

Why enough for this evidence-only PR: PR #5725 does not introduce or alter the workflow-selector behavior. It records the already completed RED/GREEN and CLI proofs for the earlier workflow-selector fix and explicitly carries the live app-server limitation.

Security/Secrets Lane

Status: pass for evidence-only scope.

The committed artifacts avoid raw tokens, auth headers, cookies, API keys, private env dumps, and service logs. The app-server failure artifact contains an ENOENT path and command output from an isolated local install attempt; it does not include credentials. PR status before this repair also showed GitGuardian Security Checks completed successfully.

Residual security risk: this artifact did not run a new secret scan locally because no secret-bearing surface was edited. CI is expected to rerun after the push.

Context/Staleness Lane

Status: pass for process scope.

Fresh context checked for this repair:

• PR #5725 blocker comment created on 2026-06-29T03:26:42Z.
• PR branch: code-yeongyu/add-workflow-selector-evidence.
• Base branch: origin/dev.
• Current PR commit before this repair: 3fbc15ee2d4a21de526656849ccb4c01dbf3dc3e.
• Existing PR status before this repair: open, mergeable, and evidence-only.

No stale source assumptions were needed because this commit does not inspect or modify the workflow-selector implementation itself.

Residual Limitations

• This artifact is a final-gate evidence report, not a new runtime QA pass.
• The Codex app-server lane remains blocked by the recorded missing packages/omo-codex/plugin/skills/ast-grep/SKILL.md during local plugin skill sync, before Codex starts. That limitation is carried from the existing evidence and is not repaired by this PR.
• Cubic was neutral/skipped and is not counted as the review-work gate.
• CI must rerun on the pushed evidence-only commit.

git diff --check origin/dev..HEAD Result

Command:

git diff --check origin/dev..HEAD

Result before adding this final-gate artifact:

• Exit code: 0
• Output: none

Post-commit verification result:

• Invocation: git diff --check origin/dev..HEAD
• Exit code: 0
• Output: none

Final verification requirement:

• Re-run the same command after the amend that records this result and before pushing.
• Required binary observable: exit code 0 with no output.