Avoid OPTIMIZE TABLE FINAL

Avoid OPTIMIZE TABLE FINAL

Impact: HIGH

OPTIMIZE TABLE ... FINAL forces immediate merge of all parts into one part per partition. This is resource-intensive and rarely necessary. ClickHouse already performs smart background merges.

Note: OPTIMIZE FINAL is not the same as FINAL. The FINAL modifier in SELECT queries may be necessary for deduplicated results in ReplacingMergeTree and is generally fine to use.

Incorrect (OPTIMIZE FINAL after inserts):

-- Running OPTIMIZE FINAL after every batch insert
INSERT INTO events SELECT * FROM staging_events;
OPTIMIZE TABLE events FINAL;  -- Expensive and unnecessary!

-- Scheduled OPTIMIZE FINAL jobs
-- Cron: 0 * * * * clickhouse-client -q "OPTIMIZE TABLE events FINAL"

Correct (let background merges work):

-- Let background merges handle optimization
INSERT INTO events SELECT * FROM staging_events;
-- Done! ClickHouse merges automatically

-- For ReplacingMergeTree deduplication, use FINAL in queries
SELECT * FROM events FINAL WHERE user_id = 123;
-- Instead of running OPTIMIZE FINAL to deduplicate

Problems with OPTIMIZE FINAL:

• Rewrites entire partition regardless of need
• Ignores the ~150 GB part size safeguard
• Can cause memory pressure or OOM errors
• Lengthy execution time for large datasets

When OPTIMIZE FINAL may be acceptable:

• Finalizing data before table freezing
• Preparing data for export operations
• One-time operations, not regular workflows

Better alternatives:

Reference: Avoid OPTIMIZE FINAL